HN Theater

The best talks and videos of Hacker News.

Hacker News Comments on
Feynman's Lost Lecture (ft. 3Blue1Brown)

minutephysics · Youtube · 722 HN points · 0 HN comments
HN Theater has aggregated all Hacker News stories and comments that mention minutephysics's video "Feynman's Lost Lecture (ft. 3Blue1Brown)".
Youtube Summary
Check out Grant’s channel: 3blue1brown: https://www.youtube.com/3blue1brown

This video recounts a lecture by Richard Feynman giving an elementary demonstration of why planets orbit in ellipses. See the excellent book by Judith and David Goodstein, "Feynman's lost lecture”, for the full story behind this lecture, and a deeper dive into its content.

Tweet referenced at the start: https://twitter.com/3blue1brown/status/1016936129117937664

Music by Nathaniel Schroeder: https://soundcloud.com/drschroeder/elizabeth-the-mouse
Music by Vincent Rubinetti: https://soundcloud.com/vincerubinetti/one-two-zeta

Support MinutePhysics on Patreon! http://www.patreon.com/minutephysics

Link to Patreon Supporters: http://www.minutephysics.com/supporters/

MinutePhysics is on twitter - @minutephysics
And facebook - http://facebook.com/minutephysics
And Google+ (does anyone use this any more?) - http://bit.ly/qzEwc6

Minute Physics provides an energetic and entertaining view of old and new problems in physics -- all in a minute!

Created by Henry Reich
HN Theater Rankings
  • Ranked #30 all time · view

Hacker News Stories and Comments

All the comments and stories posted to Hacker News that reference this video.
Sep 06, 2018 · 717 points, 51 comments · submitted by espeed
stcredzero
3Blue1Brown is one of the best math educators on YouTube. As a matter of fact, I would say he's the best I know of at the moment. I'm currently working my way through his series on diff-eq.
owenversteeg
How are his videos on linear algebra? Could they serve as a complete resource to learn linear algebra or would you want something alongside/more material?
jlos
They are absolutely amazing for the intuition but lack the mechanics, both of which are essential for linear algebra. The calculations are necessary, but without the intuition they will seem meaningless and the nuances will be difficult to remember.

I would pair with Gilbert Strang MIT open courseware and Khan Academy. The 3 together made linear algebra probably the most useful mathematics class Ive taken.

amoorthy
I loved his videos on linear algebra. Were far more intuitive than anything I studied in engineering. In particular, the way he describes what a determinant is, and what value it has, is excellent. I'm proud to be a Patreon supporter of 3Blue1Brown.
pixelperfect
His videos on linear algebra are excellent, but they are not a complete resource. If you want a comprehensive resource, search for the LA course by "maththebeautiful" on YouTube. Also check out Gilbert Strang's MIT lectures.
espeed
search for the LA course by "maththebeautiful" on YouTube. Also check out Gilbert Strang's MIT lectures.

I just realized there's a deep connection among your recommendations...Gilbert Strang was Greenfield's PhD advisor: https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/29345. Pavel has a clear and precise teaching style like Strang, and I've heard him reference Prof's Strang's courses before but didn't make the connection. Good trees produce good fruit. The small world graph and the truth of that never ceases to amaze. Good trees, good stuff.

espeed
Indeed, the MIT lectures by Prof Strang and the MathTheBeautiful videos by Prof Grinfeld provide perfect pairings to go with the enhanced visual intuition you acquire on 3Blue1Brown.

NB: MathTheBeautiful [1] is by MIT alum Pavel Grinfeld [2]. He approaches Linear Algebra from a geometric perspective as well, but with more emphasis on the mechanics of solving equations. He has a ton of videos organized into several courses, ranging from in-depth Intro to Linear Algebra courses to more advanced courses on PDEs and Tensor Calculus. Highly recommended.

Esp note his video on Legendre polynomials [3] and Why {1,x,x²} Is a Terrible Basis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYoGYQOXqTk&index=14&list=PL....

[1] MathTheBeautiful https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCr22xikWUK2yUW4YxOKXclQ

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Grinfeld

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legendre_polynomials

w1nt3rmu4e
His videos on the Fourier transform are top notch. I can't recommend watching him enough.
Analemma_
He used to do math lectures for Khan Academy, which are also very good, though they don't have the amazing visuals of the 3Blue1Brown videos.
elbear
diff-eq as in differential equations? Where's that? I don't see it on his channel.
stcredzero
My off-the-top-of-my-head mistake. Linear Algebra.
Double_Cast
Before youtube, he made a lot of videos for Khan Academy.
ZeikJT
And Sal Khan made videos on YouTube before founding Khan Academy. I find the inversion interesting for some reason :)
seanc
I can certainly say that no one else has made me tear up.
stcredzero
Not only does he have a penchant for finding geometric analogues for mathematical ideas that are neat and beautiful, his animations clarify and increase my understanding of those concepts.
abhgh
The "production quality" to use a slightly commercial term, is top-notch.
scoot
In the case of media, that would be "production values".

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/production_values

MaxLeiter
His python library for generating his visuals is open source and equally as impressive:

https://github.com/3b1b/manim

abhgh
I didn't know of this, thank you!
pishpash
Was just going to ask this. Wish there were more of these tools all around, because I bet a lot of experts have developed intuitive pictures of their own that would be good to convey directly. A big barrier to mathematics is the abstraction cost of the language. In many cases mathematical expressions are fine, but not always in mathematical physics.
teabee89
I had a profound feeling when I understood the algebraic completeness of complex numbers thanks to one of his videos about complex numbers.
adito
His later video where in the outro he mentions about going sponsor-free is the one that made me tear up

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB83DpBJQsE&feature=youtu.be...

Here's a little bit of quote from the video:

=====

So... typically this is the part where there might be some kind of sponsor message. But one thing I want to do with the channel moving ahead is to stop doing sponsored content, and instead make things just about the direct relationship with the audience.

I mean that not only in the sense of the funding model, with direct support through Patreon, but also in the sense that I think these videos can better accomplish their goal if each one feels like it's just about you and me sharing in a love of math, with no other motive, especially in the cases where viewers are students.

=====

He's really a good person. I'm glad that now he is able to do this full-time by just the support from his patreon.

MrQuincle
Yes, right then I finally thought I've to figure out this patreon thing. He deserves it.
seanc
For those who want to support this work Grant has a patreon page:

https://www.patreon.com/3blue1brown

tobmlt
Thanks for pointing that out. I'm a 1st time patreon thanks to you. This video jiggled so many good mathy connections.
fapjacks
Grant (3Blue1Brown) sounds exactly like a friend of mine named Brad. Just absolutely uncannily sounds exactly like him, even in his intonations and quirks. I've been watching his videos for over a year and using his epiphany-driving videos as the triggers to dig into specific subtopics of math that I used to hate (\cough\calc2\cough\). Turns out I love math and not just discrete math!

Anyway, my funny story about my friend Brad. I have convinced our circle of friends that Brad is actually the guy doing the 3Blue1Brown videos. He's hilarious and just started playing along at dinner one night without even knowing what I was talking about. So most of our friends now think Brad's got a huge but secret Youtube channel where he teaches incredibly insightful math perspectives.

dawidw
Maybe your friend Brad is 3Blue1Brown and uses alias Grant?
baodau
Now you want to beat him is his own game?
barcadad
There are times when I watch his videos that I wonder whether he could be an alien from an advanced civilization sent here to help accelerate our mathematical understanding and reach the singularity sooner. His explanations are 5 standard deviations better than average.
espeed
A similar concept related to elliptical constants and proportional areas, is the curve formed by the cycloid [1] of a circle, which is the curve formed by tracing a point on the circumference of a circle as it rolls across a surface from point A to point B.

For example, the fastest distance between two points is not a straight line, it's the cycloid, specifically the Brachistochrone curve [2]. This is the path light follows.

One common misconception of the cycloid is related to its arc-length. At first glance many assume the arc-length of the cycloid is equal to circumference of the circle, but this is not the case. The line-of-sight distance between the cycloid starting point A and ending point B is equal to 2πr, the circumference of the circle -- however the arc-length of the cycloid curve is 8r, which is an integer value given an integer radius. The cycloid curve is full of interesting properties, many yet to be discovered and all its implications are not yet fully understood.

Another interesting aspect of the cycloid is not only is it the fastest path, but no matter where two objects begin on the curve, they'll both traverse the curve at maximal/optimal speed and both will arrive at the bottom of the curve at the same time, regardless of the delta between their starting positions. This aspect of the cycloid is referred to as the Tautochrone curve [3].

So if you're looking for ways to distribute partitions or encode invariants in your models, data or otherwise, the geometrical aspects of elliptical and cycloidal curves are a good place to explore.

Grant did a 3Blue1Brown video with with Steven Strogatz on the Brachistochrone a few years back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cld0p3a43fU

And Vsauce did one with Adam Savage on the Brachistochrone where they build a mechanical model of one that shows it's the fastest/optimal path among different curves, and their experiment also shows the cycloid Tautochrone invariant property where objects begin up the curve at different distances apart and yet all arrive together simultaneously in constant time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=skvnj67YGmw

NB: Consider this, two seperate impulses of light beginning at different distances away from the observer, both impulses of light traveling along the optimal path at the optimal speed, and both arriving at the observer simultaneously, without bending time. And as shown above, on a cycloidal curve, this phenomenon is not unique to light.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cycloid

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brachistochrone_curve

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tautochrone_curve

speleo
>For example, the fastest distance between two points is not a straight line, it's the cycloid, specifically the Brachistochrone curve [2]. This is the path light follows.

You may be conflating [Bernoulli's solution to the Brachistochrone curve](http://www.math.rug.nl/~broer/pdf/ws-ijbc.pdf) with the optimal path for light. [Fermat's Principle](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermat%27s_principle) states that, when traveling between two points, light will always take the path that minimizes the time taken from the first point to the last. In a medium of constant refractive index (which includes free space), this results in a line.

>So if you're looking for ways to distribute partitions or encode invariants in your models, data or otherwise, the geometrical aspects of elliptical and cycloidal curves are a good place to explore.

How do you mean? What sort of data can be encoded this way and how?

> NB: Consider this, two seperate impulses of light beginning at different distances away from the observer, both impulses of light traveling along the optimal path at the optimal speed, and both arriving at the observer simultaneously, without bending time. And as shown above, on a cycloidal curve, this phenomenon is not unique to light.

Two separate impulses of light beginning at different distances away from a stationary observer will necessarily arrive at different times, otherwise you violate the basis of special relativity: the speed of light is constant and invariant of reference frame.

taejo
You can solve the brachistochrone problem using Fermat's principle, as shown in the 3blue1brown video GP is referring to. Since you're looking for the shortest time, if you can construct a lens where the speed of light is proportional to the speed of the bead on a wire, then the shortest-time wire is the path that light would take by Fermat's principle, and then you can use (an infinitesimal version of) Snell's law to find the direction of the wire at each height.
speleo
Yes, but they were saying:

>For example, the fastest distance between two points is not a straight line, it's the cycloid, specifically the Brachistochrone curve [2]. This is the path light follows.

Which is not true for free space, or any space with a constant index of refraction.

taejo
Oh yes, they do seem to be confused! espeed, if you happen to read this, the brachistochrone is the fastest path for something accelerated by a constant force (e.g. gravity near the surface of the earth).
None
None
shawn
If you haven't seen it yet, Feynman's podcast series The Character of Physical Law is quite wonderful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3mhkYbznBk
stan_rogers
You mean the Messenger Lectures of 1964? I don't think they were originally a podcast.
shawn
Podcasting was one of Feynman's lesser known discoveries. They would mail the whole spool of film to your doorstep.
cema
That would be an invention.
None
None
quakeguy
It was Done Daily, the Services had extensive labs handling film.
None
None
igtztorrero
This is what I like about Hackers News, I get very good info, like this channel, I haven't heard about it. Thanks
korbonits
> One of the most incredible feelings is when you make that new connection of understanding on an idea

To paraphrase the ongoing meme on twitter, it's better than sex

DoreenMichele
I've heard that rebutted with "You must be doing sex wrong."

I'm guessing that's why your comment is currently greyed out. (The Feynman quote below is a much better way to make such a comparison.)

jdironman
Or as Gov. Schwarzenegger once said in regards to how he felt when he worked out, or went on stage.
None
None
tobmlt
I think I need to quote guy who inspired 3blue1brown's video now too: "Physics is like sex: sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it." R.P. Feynamn, you are missed.
dang
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17927463 and marked it off-topic.
delecti
One of the most incredible feelings is when you make that new connection of understanding on an idea. Sometimes it's when two things you knew get connected in a way you didn't think existed, and sometimes it's when a complicated idea all fits into place in your mind. It's probably the drug that keeps people programming despite all the configuration hell we have to deal with on any non-trivial project (and even most trivial ones).

Every single one of 3Blue1Brown's has given me a big hit of that new brain connection drug. If you enjoy this video, I recommend checking out 3Blue1Brown's video "What does genius look like in math? Where does it come from? (Dandelin spheres)", which deals with how and why ellipses and conic sections are related. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQa_tWZmlGs

wruza
Moreover, I would recommend to watch most of their videos, at least to myself. No one could introduce me to so many ideas in so little hours without leaving any open question. This channel and its companions are fantastic if you somehow missed deep math sense at school. It is not “lets learn another seemingly useless theorem” study, it is kickstart introduction to selected interesting topics.
FiveDegrees
You may enjoy the game The Witness. The entire game is basically built around inducing that feeling.
etherealG
Seconding that. This was one of my favourite games ever because of how well it manages to achcieve that feeling.
laythea
I agree. This guy is the best math teacher I've heard.
knrz
I love the feeling you're describing! The understanding of an abstraction (or in other words, a mental model) that links two parallel thought processes in an unexpected, and fun way.

I like the term Kensho [0], thought you might too. Interested in thoughts from other people as well.

[0]: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/tMhEv28KJYWsu6Wdo/kensho

Jarwain
I like the concept of kensho. I find the idea that certain ideas can only be accurately conveyed through experience to be interesting as well.

I'm working my way through a book called "The Book Of Secrets", which has 114 different meditative techniques for different kinds of minds. One of which, is practically certain to work for any given individual.

Jul 20, 2018 · 5 points, 0 comments · submitted by pdkl95
HN Theater is an independent project and is not operated by Y Combinator or any of the video hosting platforms linked to on this site.
~ [email protected]
;laksdfhjdhksalkfj more things
yahnd.com ~ Privacy Policy ~
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.