HN Theater @HNTheaterMonth

The best talks and videos of Hacker News.

Hacker News Comments on
Real Life First Person Shooter (Chatroulette version)

RealmPictures · Youtube · 423 HN points · 0 HN comments
HN Theater has aggregated all Hacker News stories and comments that mention RealmPictures's video "Real Life First Person Shooter (Chatroulette version)".
Youtube Summary
We created a live action first-person zombie shooter in our garden - then invited unsuspecting people on chatroulette, omegle and skype to take control...

watch the behind the scenes here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpfXmcL7Ox0

@realmppictures @davidmreynolds

Many thanks to all involved!


Thanks to Red House Mysteries http://facebook.com/redhousemysteries
meet our BOSS at http://www.facebook.com/exetercosplay
Music by FoolBoyMedia http://freesound.org/people/FoolBoyMedia
and Tanner Helland
http://www.tannerhelland.com
Thanks to TeraDek for the Cube system!! http://www.teradek.com
HN Theater Rankings

Hacker News Stories and Comments

All the comments and stories posted to Hacker News that reference this video.
Aug 21, 2015 · 423 points, 41 comments · submitted by makmanalp
nsxwolf
Great stuff. Ben Folds did something similarly fun and surprising with Chatroulette:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEYxiK0kpEw

shoo
Just imagine if they had met each other on Chatroulette!
tempestn
That was so amazing. It's a great thing about technology in general; when Chatroulette was built, it's pretty clear they didn't envision people using it in that way. Often the tech has to come first, and the awesomeness follows. (Also a lot of penises, but that part probably was foreseen.)
morey
It is on HN before it is viral. The technology they put together for this is great!
jaz46
Reddit beat HN to the punch
chime
There was a movie called Gamer (2009) with a similar concept: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1034032/ (trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P2g94xQmtHw )
gear54rus
Immediately thought of it.

- I've got a bad feeling about this, Chris, Imma be honest with you

- That's right, I'm not gonna die, you are

- That is a good point

That's the inception of it we're witnessing.

camperman
This is hilarious. Reminds me of the real life remake of Goldeneye 64:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7RR5V0rmN4o

None
None
shoo
Hilarious. It reminds me of the terrible DOOM movie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45jgCxucL0k

This is much better than the movie. The interactivity and the humanity of it is wonderful.

hanniabu
That's really awesome and well done. Great job to all involved, even the players!
skeuomorf
This is pretty cool. It reminded me of [0] where a guy emulates kinda GTA-like behavior.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kb1hOCX_UVo

beyti
now, I think "video game" has a different meaning than before.

I'll be waiting for this to create this type of games and going on even multiplayer era. great stuff.

Btw I think, this would allow elder/non-tech people to enter gaming

notahacker
Corny sets. The fear of impending doom. Watchers giving not-always-very-helpful advice.

All it needs is sarcastic commentary to take me back to my childhood and the Crystal Maze, from the pre-FPS era.

untog
There's an Indiegogo for a live Crystal Maze, open to the public:

https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-crystal-maze-a-live-i...

I'm already humming the theme music.

toisanji
someone make this into a company
tempestn
I recall hearing about a real-life zombie apocalypse sim you could do in London. Ya, here you go: http://zombieexperiences.co.uk/
Ratelman
Freakin brilliant! Almost makes me want to try out Chatroulette just for the chance at something like this.
tajen
Ever thought of trying Amazon Mechanical Turk, as a worker, on the section "Image recognition"?
soylentcola
Honestly didn't realize it was still around. I remember when it first blew up in the public consciousness, a local bar had a funny event one night where they set up a computer with a webcam/mic pointed at the bar and a projector to put the video on the wall. Then we logged on to Chatroulette and let the amusement roll.

Loads of people were taken aback by talking to a bar full of people. Some were really cool and chatted with us. Of course plenty of dudes were just whackin it. Some clicked "next" when they saw the bar full of people but at least one just kept going until we had to get up and click "next". Pretty fun idea but they only did it a few times before the novelty of Chatroulette mostly wore off.

arc_of_descent
Innovation!
downandout
This is awesome! But hopefully it doesn't inspire the first Periscope-based mass-shooting.
kendallpark
This is amazing.

It also speaks to the absurdity of FPSes. I was laughing so hard at all the little FPS tropes. Like how the guns were cached in "obvious" places or how the guy knew there would be something of use inside the conspicuous pot outside.

"Okay, now dual-wield the pistols." --said no one ever in real life

abandonliberty
The quest for realism is interesting. Reduction to absurdity: a fully realistic FPS would cause PTSD and mental trauma to its players.

What do we actually want to create with our games? Complete lack of realism can be fun (e.g. surgeon simulator), and these games are proliferating. Games with more realism may be able to create more meaning and insight for their audience.

rawTruthHurts
But this is mistaking games for real life, right?
InclinedPlane
They tested dual-wielding on mythbusters, it's absolutely of no advantage. You can't shoot faster or better since the gating factor is not the gun (you can shoot semi-automatic pistols extremely rapidly) it's the ability to focus and aim more than anything, both of which are hampered by dual-wielding not improved.

P.S. In terms of raw cool-factor, it's hard to beat this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tEYcUSQDyw

I won't spoil it by describing it.

wingerlang
> it's the ability to focus and aim more than anything

But if you're swamped with zombies, then maybe simply having more firepower is an advantage.

scott_karana
Then, alternate between the using the two pistols one-handedly.
InclinedPlane
You can empty a magazine in seconds, being able to reload quickly with two hands is vastly superior to anything else.
Retric
There are a few examples of people using two guns with belt fed ammo at the same time. Mobility and accuracy suffers, but some times dumping thousands of extra rounds a minute down range is simply worth the sacrifice.

The other advantage of using two guns is you get to let one cool down while reloading the other which helps avoid melting the barrel. This eventually ends up with a Gatling gun. Which is arguably hexa-wielding.

wingerlang
How about shooting with the double wielded guns. Then simply dropping the second one to reload. That way you would get the extra firepower for what it is worth. Then you can go reload super fast after that.
InclinedPlane
It takes maybe 2 or 3 seconds or so to unload even a double stack magazine (with, say, 20 rounds). There's really zero advantage to dual wielding.
wingerlang
But we were talking about a situation where you find two guns.
sgk284
Then pocket the second gun until the first runs out. If you've got a buddy, get the zombies coming through a fatal funnel. You shoot straight at the funnel while your buddy reloads the inactive gun. This allows you to maximize accuracy while the lead never stops flying down the hallway (until you run out of ammo).
wingerlang
But there are zombies on each side of you, and your "buddy" is just some chatroulette guy who can't help you.
EGreg
What if exactly 14 zombies were coming from both sides?
piptastic
I think you're forgetting the obvious solution of having tons of preloaded magazines strapped to you.

Single button magazine ejection, slam your Uzis down onto fresh 100 round magazines. Bonus points for an automated system that moves the next set of magazines into the perfect arms length position at your side for the next reload.

Two handed reloads are for chumps when you are fighting zombies. You would be the guy I'm standing behind to give me that extra few seconds while they're busy eating you. That way once I finish off your attackers I can pick up your freshly loaded (but unspent) gun. And triple-wield!!

afarrell
The second problem is that ammunition is heavy and carrying an infinite amount of it increases your need for food and water in a world where your biggest threats are cholera a dysentery. And unless you want to find yourself among jittery poorly-prepared armed people, you can't just show up to Cabellas to steal more ammo.
smtucker
Unfortunately it is hard to scientifically test the rule of cool
kendallpark
I think a case could be made for dual needlers though, if they ever exist in the future. ;)
n0us
They forgot to use the crosshairs and auto-aim
abandonliberty
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7DpCellB_UQ

An example of what (a world record holder) can do with a revolver.

HN Theater is an independent project and is not operated by Y Combinator or any of the video hosting platforms linked to on this site.
~ yaj@
;laksdfhjdhksalkfj more things
yahnd.com ~ Privacy Policy ~
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.