HN Theater @HNTheaterMonth

The best talks and videos of Hacker News.

Hacker News Comments on
The US electrical system is not 120V

Technology Connections · Youtube · 7 HN points · 6 HN comments
HN Theater has aggregated all Hacker News stories and comments that mention Technology Connections's video "The US electrical system is not 120V".
Youtube Summary
It's more than 120V. It's even more than the other 120V! It is the sum of the two (and sometimes a different two!) that makes us who we are. Learn about the US electrical system in this not-at-all snarky video!

Would you care for some links?

Firstly are foremostly, here's that video about fans I referenced;
https://youtu.be/hQ3GW7lVBWY

And other assorted goodies!
Technology Connextras (the second channel that stuff goes on sometimes):
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClRwC5Vc8HrB6vGx6Ti-lhA
Technology Connections on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/TechConnectify
The TC Subreddit
https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections

This channel is supported through viewer contribution on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration!
https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections

And thank you to the following patrons!

Yaniv , Francis Fisher, The War Academy, Conor Killeen, Jay , Dave Anderson, Eric Hansen, Dane Peterson, Jeremy Kitchen, Audin Malmin, Adam D. Ruppe, Rafał Wiosna, Matthew Giraitis, Kevin Landrigan, Carl Yazbek, Logan Kriete, Hunter Schwisow, Matt Falcon, Paul Williams, Brent LaRowe, Lurker239 , Felix Freiberger, James Ryan, Lukas Komischke, h.drew foy, Jason Nevins, Jeffrey , BlancoGrande , Stephen Pick, Technicalleigh , Adam Coddington, Lolucoca , Steven Metcalf, Justin Talbot, Christopher Jett, SovietBear , Mike Mason, Techmoan , Kotanu , Christopher Luna, Paul Mills, Brian G. Shacklett, Chris Hartl, Andre, Tony , Matthew Baron, Mark Critchley, Andres Plaza, Charlie Hankin, Craig Leverenz, Casey Kikendall, Sebi Jecklin, Warmo , The8TrackKid , Michael Snowden, Julian Rapoport, Christopher Bassett, Ryan Cozzubbo, Marcus Schwartz, Matt Taylor, Patrick Musson, Lars JJ, Richard Lindsey, Peek , blouerat , Robert Toth, Marc Ethier, Thijs Dortmann, Brady Brown, Stein Strindhaug, foophoof , Ernie Smith, Christopher Dickey, Andrey Tarantsov, PatreonDotComSlashAsterios - $37k legal bill, Mitchel J. Mullin II, Matthew Razza, Trix Farrar, Marco Anastasi, Pavlo Pravdiukov, Howard Kraut, Mike Bailey, Matthias Dienelt, Michael Bernstein, Kevin Strehl, Yona , neko , Grayson Lang, Paul Virdone, Jeffery Grajkowski, Eric Merrill, Stefan Berndtsson, Michael Sims, Christopher Leidich, Sean Reigle, Mike Friedman, André Waage Sørensen, Sam Redfern, Tully , Chris LeChien, fussel , Luc Ritchie, Eric Romero, Ryan Hardy, Ewen McNeill, Henrik Ripa, Albin Flyckt, Shane Zamora, Alex Ilyin, Yorick Terweijden, Andrew "FastLizard4" Adams, Avi Drissman, Phil Taprogge, Sam Witney, Jonathan Skowronek, Pieter van der Eems, Brian Condron, Reto Jost, Vince Terranova, Andrew Montagne, David Scott, Mike Nichols, Brandon Enright, James Fialho, Christian Torelli, The Paul Allen, toasterking , Nick Pollard, Manalope , Andy S, Robert , Johan Greefkes, Jacob Dixon, Rob Kefford, Benjamin A., Nathaniel , Michel Sievers, Colin , MrHammond , Aaron Rennow, Bee Jay, Countzero , Kodapan , Eli Krumholz, Guillaume Tremblay-Beaumont, Sha Nasti, Laria , Stephen Hinton, thegeoffreak , Bob Slovick, Jib Systems, Andrew Rosenwinkel, Grazer , Bob B, Mike Noe, Scott Rowland, Steve Kralik, Your name, Kirill Polstainen, Felix Winkelnkemper, BoostCookie , 98abaile , Owen O Byrne, Sebastian Sparrer, Matt Mullett, Andrew Bade, Paul Moffat, Max , Alessandro Robert Nilsen, Ryan Benson, Neil Forker, Vincent Beelte, Johnni Winther, Mark Hesse, Nathan Blubaugh, lululombard , Armando Fox, Nelson , William Evans, VilleS , Anton Afanasev, Ray , Liam O'Flynn, Petter Feltenstedt, Gideon Ritter, Oliver Lee, Lennart Sorensen, Mitch Radoll, Viorel , Reaghan Kekeis, lohphat , Vivian Pypher, Brandon Whiting, Zachary Hazlett, Peter Stewart, Robin Johnsen, Phia Westfall, Tom Rolfe, Jeremey Hastings, Mark Wayt, Arthur Robillard, Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog, Ramon Gamez, Garrett Rabenold, Vaughn B., Breunie Ploeg, Benjamin Cirker, Braden McDorman, Julien Oster, Jake Hickman, Trae Palmer, Lennart Rosam, Chris Wallace, Matt Shea, Jason Baker, Galimaufry , Aaron Helton, Michael Holmes, Kevin Hollywood, Trey Harris, Peter Pfundstein, Wilhelm Screamer, Alan Boyd, Mat Stu, RYAN INGOGLIA, Thomas Kolanus, Brett Morgan, William Kisley, Daniel Johnson, Potch , Reemt Rühmkorf, Robin Rattay, Bruce Justyn, Rae McIntosh, Justin D, Adam Zawisza, LordJakson , Triancia , Matthew Holder, Joshua Moncrieff, Max Barnash, Microfrost , Mitch Schenk, Juan Olivares, Mike Bird, Emmett Ray, Michael Shaffer, Sputnik , Jason Spriggs, Gregory Kumpula, Zach Turner, Tom Burns, Daniel Pf, Yung Kim, John W Campbell, Matthew Jones, Slappy826 , Steven Ingles, Robert Howcroft, Some Random, Jeremy Heiden, Vince Batchelor, Peter Sarossy, Tracy Cogsdill, Matt Allaire, Guy
HN Theater Rankings

Hacker News Stories and Comments

All the comments and stories posted to Hacker News that reference this video.
The US (and CA) runs on 240V as well, it's just split in half for smaller appliances. See requisite Technology Connections video:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMmUoZh3Hq4

My stove and clothes dryer are certainly not 120V.

tjoff
In the same way that 240V countries run on 400V as well then?
Kirby64
Sort of. Outside of industrial or businesses, my understanding is that it is rare to see multi-phase power (400V) used in power applications. You may get 3 phases into your house, but the phases are used separately (each at 240V) for most things in residential.
tjoff
Stoves are pretty much always at three phases unless it is something like a small summer-house

Washing machines too I've heard.

throw0101c
> In the same way that 240V countries run on 400V as well then?

400V is not sent to your home (AFAICT) in 240V-based countries. There is no connection at any box in a typical home where you can connect two wires to get 400V. It could be distributed in three-phase 400V on the street, but most homes do not have three-phases delivered, generally only hot+neutral.

In US/CA homes there are two wires (L1+L2) that give you a 240V, and that 240V is used for larger equipment. There just happens to be a third (N) that allows for 120V as well.

Are there typically any 400V appliances in a (e.g.) EU home?

There's a lot of misconceptions about US electricity. This video does a nice job at pointing out the good and the bad.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMmUoZh3Hq4&ab_channel=Techn...

There's probably a large overlap between software people and people who subscribe to Technology Connections: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMmUoZh3Hq4
Relevant video: Technology Connections, "The US electrical system is not 120V", where there is a (long) discussion of how the breaker panel works and how you get 240V.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMmUoZh3Hq4

teddyh
By the same definition, the European electrical system is not 240V, it’s 380V.
frosted-flakes
Europe does not have split phase electrical service. Three-phase service is ultimately how the US system works, same as Europe; it's just that entire neighbourhoods or streets will run off a single 240 V phase rather than each house getting all three phases (industrial buildings commonly have three-phase service).
jacquesm
> Europe does not have split phase electrical service.

This is incorrect in many places. Yes, you will have three phase electrical service pulled right into the distribution panel, but in many places all you will receive is a single phase because only one of the three possible fuses is installed.

If you want three phase hookup you just pay your utility company a small fee, they come out to install the extra two fuses and in some cases they'll upgrade your consumption meter to three phase.

> Three-phase service is ultimately how the US system works, same as Europe; it's just that entire neighbourhoods or streets will run off a single 240 V phase rather than each house getting all three phases (industrial buildings commonly have three-phase service).

In the US plenty of the last leg of the distribution network is single phase, in the EU it is almost everywhere three phase, except for some rural areas in former East block countries. Typically a step down transformer will take the distribution voltage and reduce it to something the residents can use directly, houses are then alternating in which of the three fuses is placed (R/S/T) to ensure relatively even distribution of the load.

Here you see a three phase domestic hookup (for instance because of an electric range):

https://www.superflink.nl/media/wysiwyg/1-of-3-fase-aansluit...

and here a single phase one:

https://www.circuitsonline.net/forum/file/58210/forum-post

In this case the 'S' leg of the transformer is used to power the dwelling.

frosted-flakes
What you describe is not split phase. Split phase is where one 240V phase is split into two 120V legs offset 180°, with a center-tapped 0V neutral.
jacquesm
See my comment elsewhere in this thread where I think I pretty much exhaustively treated the subject.

And no, that particular version of 'split phase' is not +120V and -120V, this is not DC that we are talking about. Europe used to have a lot of that kind of split phase but we 'phased it out' to use a cheap pun.

So now the term single phase is used to indicate what you typically get delivered to your house and we don't further subdivide it. This is good because it means you can run much thinner wire due to reduced current. You do get a bigger whack if you accidentally end up touching the phase or if there is an internal short in an ungrounded device that exposes that phase to the outside (this should never happen). In North America 240 V center tapped off a single drop transformer is the norm for residential delivery.

frosted-flakes
I should have said two 120V legs offset 180°.
jacquesm
That's accurate. In NL until the 70's we had two levels of delivery, 127V (phase to ground, transformer in 'star' configuration) and 220V (phase to phase, transformer in 'delta' configuration). The latter is interesting because it doesn't actually have a neutral wire at all.

The former was close enough that you could get away with plugging in US or Japanese devices, but if there was anything synchronous in there you'd be out of luck (50 Hz vs 60 Hz). Then 220V became the standard and now it is all 240.

Interesting tidbit: there was so much inertia from older systems that needed upgrading in this that it took until 2004 until the last of it (the 127->220V change) was finally done.

jacquesm
This is an incorrect interpretation of the differences between the two systems.

In the EU the 380V (now nominally 400V) relates to tri-phase, the 240V to the voltage between a phase and ground.

Tri-phase power in the United States is available to residential consumers and very light industry (say a small farm) at a number of different voltages up to 480V.

The 240V in the united states is between two 'lives' that are both 120V and that are usually delivered on a center tapped transformer with the center being the neutral. Adding those two together gives you the 240V, but it all comes from a single phase, it's just a center tapped transformer with a 240V winding as the secondary.

You can easily see this when you look at your typical drop transformer that will take a 10KV low voltage distribution line to domestic voltages, where three phase power is required you'll see three transformers in a bank, one for each phase. A typical residence will have only one because in North America single phase power is the norm for distribution.

https://www.mytpu.org/wp-content/uploads/wires.jpg

Is pretty typical in NA.

So a typical drop will have a distribution neutral and a single distribution phase going in to the transformer and three wires coming back out: L1, N and L2 with L1 and L2 being the outside legs of the winding. In your distribution panel you then add your residential ground.

jacquesm
bugfix: the 240V to the voltage between a phase and ground

This is possible, but more likely is a phase-to-phase in a delta configured transformer. In that case there is no ground delivered to the distribution panel, just two phases (or three).

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jMmUoZh3Hq4
colejohnson66
I haven’t watched the video yet, so I don’t know if he addresses this, but: considering many devices with a switching PSU support “universal” voltage, plugging a US style plug into a 220/240V source would probably be fine.
Jan 19, 2021 · 4 points, 0 comments · submitted by mulmen
Jul 17, 2020 · 2 points, 0 comments · submitted by naetius
Jun 22, 2020 · 1 points, 0 comments · submitted by notRobot
HN Theater is an independent project and is not operated by Y Combinator or any of the video hosting platforms linked to on this site.
~ yaj@
;laksdfhjdhksalkfj more things
yahnd.com ~ Privacy Policy ~
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.