Hacker News Comments on
Is India The Next China?
Bloomberg Quicktake
·
Youtube
·
10
HN points
·
2
HN comments
- This course is unranked · view top recommended courses
Hacker News Stories and Comments
All the comments and stories posted to Hacker News that reference this video.How much of this is due to COVID?This video considers India the next production hub, especially considering young vs. old population ratio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKNPP8nwD_E
⬐ HeavenFoxThere have been two theories:- Since China controlled the pandemic via strict lockdown, where one cannot leave their apartments / housing compound for ANY reason, couples would be bored and get busy in bed to pass the time, resulting in a surge in birth rate.
- Also because of the strict lockdown, couples would be wary of having babies in such uncertainty. For example, if a woman gets pregnant and their compound goes into lockdown, she would have trouble getting prenatal care. Even if they can go to the hospital, they are afraid they will get COVID there.
So far it seems the second theory is closer to truth.
⬐ hlbjhblbljib⬐ dqpbIt's hard for new couples to form, when you cannot leave your apartmentAccording to Google, China only really had a problem with Covid for about one month in the beginning. Since then, country wide, cases have been in the tens per day.⬐ outside1234⬐ zinekellerAnd Hong Kong is democratic too⬐ justbakerOh yeah, that’s entirely believable…⬐ buzzertI would consider the fact that 13 million people in Xi'an are currently locked down for the third week in a row[0] a continuing problem.[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/07/china/china-xian-outbreak-ana...
⬐ dqpbI see. That does sound quite bad.Unlikely. Not saying that there's no effect, but even without COVID it's already setting alarms at CCP.The declining population of China is a well-known problem so much that its one-child policy was progressively loosened and the scrapped altogether. Essentially, if the Chinese people (collectively) decide to focus on growing a 3+ child family, this population crunch will decline, but it seems that in major urban areas the people in general voiced that the policies might not be pro-family enough to reverse this shrinkage (with even some pointing to practices that indirectly discourage bringing up a family like workplace discrimination on pregnant women).
⬐ throwaway293dAlthough I don't have any data to back it up, but I think the financial burden on children of one-child policy to support their parents made many of them turn away from having kids. It's already hard enough to support their parents, why make it even hard by supporting another generation. So now, it's a downward spiral where only the financially secure will choose to have kids.CCP certainly succeeded in curbing the population. The question now is whether they can reverse course. My gut feeling is that as China becomes more developed, people will want less kids (as everything gets more expensive), making it likely they will fail.
Is India next? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKNPP8nwD_E
⬐ mgh2Or just plain local real state: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29774075