Hacker News Comments on
Stanford Seminar - IPFS and the Permanent Web
stanfordonline
·
Youtube
·
12
HN points
·
6
HN comments
- This course is unranked · view top recommended courses
Hacker News Stories and Comments
All the comments and stories posted to Hacker News that reference this video.Still it's early days, but watch these talks on IPFS[1] and Golem[2] to get a basic idea.
WOW, very difficult. Anyone have a link?They talked a little about it in this video [1], but that's all I could find.
Thanks very much to Christian and John for writing a much needed detailed article :)Some more links for people to check out:
## (upcoming) IPLD "merkleized JSON" format:
- improves upon our basic format to make it much more pleasant to build things on top of ipfs.
- JSON meets CBOR meets Merkle-linking
- mini-spec: https://github.com/ipfs/specs/blob/master/merkledag/ipld.md
## answers to some common questions i've read on this page:
- content model / replication: https://github.com/ipfs/faq/issues/47
- how resolution works: https://github.com/ipfs/faq/issues/48#issuecomment-152917088
- how IPNS / mutable linking works: https://github.com/ipfs/faq/issues/16
- this is a very poor answer, sorry, i'll write up a post or paper on it.
- for now if interested, see the QConf slides below, specifically slides ~110 to ~130 -- the DNS, IPRS, SFS/Mazieres linking, IPNS parts.
## These repos have interesting "lab notebook" style discussions:
- https://github.com/ipfs/notes/issues
- https://github.com/ipfs/apps/issues
## deep dive talk at stanford:
- video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUVmypx9HGI
- slides: lmk if you want them, i'll pdf them up
## talk at ethereum's devcon1 covering blockchain uses
- video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewpIi1y_KDc
- slides (interesting bits start at slide ~70): https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmUgRq7QfmRbPw5kXqwSs1TRtPDBXMoDNiYwJQg...
## talk at qconf sf (similar to above)
- in this talk i discuss a bunch of datastructure stuff, including using IPFS for PKI, for arbitrary dns-like records, for name systems, for CRDTs, and so on.
- unfort video will be released in march: https://qconsf.com/video-schedule
- slides (intersting bits starts at slide 80): https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmPpYmdSEKspjgXxVyGK9UMHV54fKZS8MwJjppg...
Is this all centralized?How about something completely decentralized, but permanent:
The InterPlanetary File System (IPFS)
⬐ chc4I'm all for IPFS, but I think you're missing the forest for the trees. Crypto is hard, especially PKI. KeybaseFS is crypto first, global FS second, while IPFS just says "do crypto yourself" - which, as we've seen with email and texting and literally everything else, doesn't work.I would love for KeybaseFS to work via IPFS instead of their own servers. But pointing at IPFS as a /replacement/ for this crypto+FS project is disingenious.
⬐ amelius⬐ hatsunearuI think parent only wanted to give examples of what direction we should be looking in.30 second caveats:- You still have to host yourself, since you don't get free hosting.
- Not encrypted, so you gotta add the encryption in yourself.
⬐ manyosoNot true. IPFS is encrypted and with pluggable PKI too!https://youtu.be/HUVmypx9HGI?t=3210
And you do not have to host yourself once your content is distributed. That is what makes it permanent!
⬐ kevincox⬐ lewisl9029You don't have to, but unless someone decides to "pin" it it might just disappear at any time. So you better pin it yourself or find someone reliable to pin it for you.⬐ toomuchtodo⬐ richdougherty> or find someone reliable to pin it for you.The Internet Archive will eventually be the "pin" of last resort.
⬐ icebrainingFor encrypted personal files?⬐ toomuchtodo⬐ greglindahlNo, this was IPFs being discussed (content addressable web).⬐ icebrainingYes, but we were talking in the context of the grandparent post "IPFS is encrypted and with pluggable PKI too!", not of publicly accessible files.And/or someone will make a business out of pinning files.For public files, I hope that there will be several organizations organizing multiple long-term pins of files.
⬐ toomuchtodoThat's the best part! Anyone could be paid to pin!Home users with enough bandwidth and storage. Existing CDNs. New cloud storage entrants (Backblaze).
Literally anyone with an internet connection and storage would be able to securely serve your content.
EDIT: I just saw your profile :) Thanks for the work you do at the IA!
Here's an IPFS issue about Keybase integration: https://github.com/ipfs/notes/issues/48Decentralized doesn't mean you need to host it yourself.Decentralized simply gives you the additional option to host it yourself. It also does not preclude free hosting.
Example: email.
The case for IPFS to combat these walled gardens:https://m.youtube.com/watch?ebc=ANyPxKqMiNbStnEQHC-kiEBSd1jI...